360° Coverage : Modi's elevation tipping point for Indian politics (Comment)

9 Updates
Modi's elevation tipping point for Indian politics (Comment)
Photo Credit: SAM PANTHAKY, Getty Images

Modi's elevation tipping point for Indian politics (Comment)

Jun 12 2013, 5:12am CDT | by

The controversial BJP decision to elevate hardliner Narendra Modi to run the party's campaign in 2014 elections and ruthlessly sideline a leader such as L.K. Advani is bound to damage its image, but let us not forget that it is a decisive victory for the RSS, which forced BJP President Rajnath Singh, from behind the scenes, to go ahead with the drastic step.

The controversial BJP decision to elevate hardliner Narendra Modi to run the party's campaign in 2014 elections and ruthlessly sideline a leader such as L.K. Advani is bound to damage its image, but...

Filed under: news

YouTube Videos Tweets

 
 
 

1 year ago

Modi's elevation tipping point for Indian politics (Comment)

Jun 12 2013, 5:12am CDT | by

The controversial BJP decision to elevate hardliner Narendra Modi to run the party's campaign in 2014 elections and ruthlessly sideline a leader such as L.K. Advani is bound to damage its image, but let us not forget that it is a decisive victory for the RSS, which forced BJP President Rajnath Singh, from behind the scenes, to go ahead with the drastic step.

The controversial BJP decision to elevate hardliner Narendra Modi to run the party's campaign in 2014 elections and ruthlessly sideline a leader such as L.K. Advani is bound to damage its image, but let us not forget that it is a decisive victory for the RSS, which forced BJP President Rajnath Singh, from behind the scenes, to go ahead with the drastic step.

Hardline groups such as RSS, Shiv Sena and Vishwa Hindu Parishad have been waiting in the wings for decades to somehow harden the BJP's Hindu nationalist image by encouraging leaders like Modi to lead the party campaigns and also the party.

Surprisingly, some BJP leaders and most of the Indian media are describing it as a personal feud between a senior and a junior leader of the party. But apparently it is more than that. Advani realizes that Modi is perceived as a divisive and controversial force that can damage the party's chances of heading a coalition in 2014. Who can deny that Advani is the same leader who in the past did step aside when he realized that Atal Behari Vajpayee would prove to be a better prime minister for the party than him.

Anyhow, the appointment of Modi as the chairman of the BJP's 2014 Election Management Committee has set the stage for next year's Lok Sabha elections, which now will be a contest between Modi on one side and Congress vice president Rahul Gandhi on the other. So the fight will now be between the two parivars - the Sangh Parivar and the Gandhi Parivar.

It is very convenient for the Sangh Parivar to say that the ongoing feud is nothing more than a manifestation of the internal democracy of the party. But the fact remains that the old guard has openly expressed its concern that elevating a known Hindu hardliner as the top national leader in the party could be a big gamble in today's India. The simple reason is that the number of hardline Hindu voters in India is much less than the total number of liberal Hindus and minorities combined.

Modi sees his leadership as the best bet for the BJP in 2014 polls. He cites his three consecutive victories in the Gujarat elections, his rapport with India's top industrialists and the economic development he has achieved in Gujarat as his top qualities to be projected as the prime ministerial candidate. Although his personality is not charismatic, his ability to rebutting the Congress party slogans is great and his criticism of some of the present government policies is valid. But the problem is he also carries the taint of the 2002 Gujarat riots and an almost visceral hate for Muslims.

There was a time in 2004 when the most accepted BJP leader and then prime minister Vajpayee also distanced himself from Modi. He had asked Modi not to discriminate between Hindus and Muslims in the aftermath of the 2002 Gujarat violence and had pushed for his resignation as chief minister. And when the BJP lost the elections, Vajpayee held the violence in Gujarat as one of the main reasons and acknowledged that not removing Modi immediately after the Gujarat violence was a mistake. Modi, instead had tried to equate the Gujarat violence with the 9/11 terror attacks in the US and responded to a newspaper's criticism that compared him to Hitler by saying: "I have not read and I would not like to read (the criticism)."

Perception matters a lot in politics. And when one talks to Indian voters and watches the TV talk shows about Indian politics, Modi's image comes across as a dictatorial leader who has never felt any need to express any regrets about the 2002 riots, who is ruthlessly in a hurry to rule India and who doesn't care about the country's minorities and feels that his party can win the elections with the support of just the Hindu majority of the country.

Modi, according to some experts, comes across as a crude politician who does not have any political "sanskars" and does not have an open mind and the charisma for running a country like India. The way Modi sent his supporters to demonstrate outside Advani's home in Delhi; the way he treated a whistle blower (senior IPS officer Kuldip Sharma) who exposed some of his controversial actions, and the way he allegedly shunned his wife are some clear indications that he can use any means to achieve what he thinks is right. Deep down he is an authoritarian man ill at ease with dissent. Even his wife has alleged that she is afraid of losing her job and livelihood if she says something against her politically powerful husband.

The bottom line is that Modi is now set to face Rahul Gandhi, who, in a total contrast to Modi's "clamouring approach" for the prime ministerial post, is using the "renunciation approach" with a touch of magnanimity. Rahul Gandhi has said he is in no hurry to become the prime minister because at first he wants to work for the unity of his party.

But Rahul Gandhi also has a perception problem. He comes across as a young man who has no experience at all of holding any position in the government or otherwise. His critics say he is surrounded by the most ineffective cronies led by a very insecure adviser like Kanishka Singh, who for his own job security has been limiting Rahul Gandhi's exposure. The critics also say if he becomes the prime minister, it will not be because of his ability but because he is a member of the Gandhi dynasty.

But it is also clear that Rahul Gandhi's 'sanskars' are solid. When he says becoming the prime minister is not his top priority, he means it. He did not say he does not want to become the prime minister, but only that it is not his top priority and that the party comes first.

Rahul has perhaps inherited this quality from his mother. For years after Rajiv Gandhi's assassination, Sonia Gandhi kept on rejecting the party leadership until one day all senior politicians, who were fighting over it, forced her to become the Congress chief.

So at a time when cracks are appearing in the BJP's unity, Rahul Gandhi comes across as a Congress leader who is trying to unite his Congress party by making it more democratic and giving more power to the middle ranks.

The young Congress vice-president, it seems, is following his father's footsteps. But, unlike his father, he doesn't seem to be in a hurry to implement the changes overnight. Rahul Gandhi, with his hard work and interaction with the grassroots for the past nine years, probably realizes, more than his father did, how murky and ruthless Indian politics can be. And perhaps he also realizes that once he is able to democratize the party and empower the neglected ranks in the Congress, he will automatically become their natural choice for leading them in parliament.

Whatever the results, one thing is certain that next year's Lok Sabha elections are bound to have far reaching repercussions for Indian politics. Also, the RSS victory in forcing the BJP to sideline the more acceptable moderate leaders and elevate a Hindu hardliner for the 2014 polls can prove to be a tipping point for the world's largest democracy.

(Ravi M. Khanna has covered the South Asian political scene for Voice of America from Washington and New Delhi for more than 24 years. He can be contacted at ravimohankhanna@gmail.com)

IANS

Source: IANS

 
Update
9

Tweets

 
 
Update
8

5 days ago

World View: AQAP Announces Support for Islamic State

Aug 25 2014 3:11pm CDT | Source: Big Government

This morning's key headlines from GenerationalDynamics.com Violence flares on India/Pakistan border in Kashmir Narendra Modi increases tensions in Jammu and Kashmir AQAP announces support for Islamic State Violence flares on India/Pakistan border in Kashmir Two Indian soldiers and four militants were killed on Saturday when terrorists from the Pakistan side of the Line of Control (LoC) in the disputed region of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) crossed the border into ...
Source: Big Government   Full article at: Big Government
 

 
Update
7

1 week ago

Obsessed With India, Pakistan Risks Anarchy

Aug 22 2014 5:59pm CDT | Source: Politics - The Huffington Post

This article also appears in YaleGlobal. NEW DELHI: The elaborate diplomatic dance between India and Pakistan has been interrupted once again. The two sides remain far from a major breakthrough in their troubled relationship. As long as the Pakistani Army continues to view India as an existential threat and maintains its grip over security policy, the twain may never achieve permanent peace. India has called off the meeting betwee ...
Source: Politics - The Huffington Post   Full article at: Politics - The Huffington Post
 

 
Update
6

2 weeks ago

U.S., India Seek to Move Defense Ties Beyond Arms Sales

Aug 12 2014 7:00pm CDT | Source: World Politics Review

Last week, U.S. Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel visited India to sound out Prime Minister Narendra Modi on the Defense Trade and Technology Initiative, the “centerpiece” of the U.S.-India security relationship. To sustain ties with a new Indian government focused on leveraging weapons manufacturing for jobs, Washington realizes it must move beyond arms sales t ...
Source: World Politics Review   Full article at: World Politics Review
 

 
Update
5

2 weeks ago

Trump: "Money Will Pour into India" Thanks to Narendra Modi

Aug 12 2014 3:02pm CDT | Source: Big Government

Visiting India to open the gleaming Trump Tower Mumbai, Real Estate magnate Donald Trump heaped praise upon India’s newly elected conservative Prime Minister Narendra Modi, predicting that his free market policies will unleash an unprecedented wave of foreign investment into India.   "I see India as a great place to invest,” Trump told reporters in the country’s commercial hub. “Money will pour into India,” claiming India’s new leader ...
Source: Big Government   Full article at: Big Government
 

 
Update
3

3 weeks ago

Strategizing Kukis' Political Demands

Aug 4 2014 6:00pm CDT | Source: Politics - The Huffington Post

The leaders of the two Kuki armed groups -- the United Peoples' Front (UPF) and the Kuki National Organization (KNO) -- are again heading to New Delhi with the hope of materializing a political dialogue with representatives of the central government. A meeting with officials of the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) is likely to take place within the next few days. The meeting will be the first high-level engagement between the two sides under Prime Minister Narendra ...
Source: Politics - The Huffington Post   Full article at: Politics - The Huffington Post
 

 
Update
2

4 weeks ago

Indian PM's Nepal Visit to Boost Energy, Infrastructure Cooperation

Jul 30 2014 4:20pm CDT | Source: Politics - The Huffington Post

The upcoming visit of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to Nepal is set to deepen relations between the two nations in various spheres. This is a win-win scenario for both countries: India's role is crucial for Nepal as it enters a new era of democracy, change and development, while harnessing Nepal's resources can help solve India's pressing energy needs. Modi's visit to Kathmandu is an incredible opportu ...
Source: Politics - The Huffington Post   Full article at: Politics - The Huffington Post
 

 
Update
1

6 weeks ago

Sustainable Development: An Agenda for India

Jul 19 2014 4:47pm CDT | Source: Politics - The Huffington Post

Over the next 18 months, the world is set to witness three major international events that could be potentially game-changing in efforts aimed at addressing global warming. The first would be the UN Summit next September revolving around the post 2015 development agenda; the second would be centered on the climate negotiations, which are supposed to culminate in Paris in December 2015; and the third would be the meeting to explore a new agreement on finance for development, which will t ...
Source: Politics - The Huffington Post   Full article at: Politics - The Huffington Post
 

 

Don't miss ...

 

<a href="/latest_stories/all/all/8" rel="author">Luigi Lugmayr</a>
Luigi is the founding Chief Editor of I4U News and brings over 15 years experience in the technology field to the ever evolving and exciting world of gadgets. He started I4U News back in 2000 and evolved it into vibrant technology magazine.
Luigi can be contacted directly at ml@i4u.com. Luigi posts regularly on LuigiMe.com about his experience running I4U.

 

blog comments powered by Disqus

Latest stories

Abe glad Modi visited Kyoto
Kyoto, Aug 31 (IANS) Japan Prime Minister Shinzo Abe Sunday said he was happy his Indian counterpart Narendra Modi toured the country's ancient capital Kyoto.
 
 
Modi leaves for Tokyo
Kyoto, Aug 31 (IANS) Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi departed for Tokyo Sunday evening, on the second day of his five-day visit to Japan.
 
 
Philippines seeking defence ties with India after China's moves
Manila, Aug 31 (IANS) Worried over increasingly aggressive moves of China to stake claim on disputed reefs in the South China Sea, the Philippines is looking at establishing defence cooperation with allies, including India, a top official said here.
 
 
Five new monkey species discovered
London, Aug 31 (IANS) Conservationists have discovered five new monkey species in South America that have, since, been added to the animal record books.
 
 
 

Latest from the Network

Aaron Paul enjoying 'lighter' role
Aaron Paul is enjoying starring in a ''lighter'' show after 'Breaking Bad'. The 34-year-old star played meth manufacturer Jesse Pinkman in the US drama series for five years and while he is pleased to be lending his...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Self-critical Ariana Grande
Ariana Grande says she's too critical of her appearance. The 21-year-old beauty insists that although she's an international pop star, she still feels the same pressure to look good as other young women and is trying...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Lily Allen's husband doesn't mind marriage songs
Lily Allen says her husband is comfortable with her discussing intimate details of their personal life. The London-born singer is preparing to hit the road with material from her new album 'Sheezus' and Lily insists her...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Abe glad Modi visited Kyoto
Kyoto, Aug 31 (IANS) Japan Prime Minister Shinzo Abe Sunday said he was happy his Indian counterpart Narendra Modi toured the country's ancient capital Kyoto. "I am very glad that Modi enjoyed the cultural heritage of...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Modi leaves for Tokyo
Kyoto, Aug 31 (IANS) Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi departed for Tokyo Sunday evening, on the second day of his five-day visit to Japan. "Goodbye Kyoto," the external affairs ministry spokesman tweeted, as Modi...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
For DINK couples, outsourcing parenthood is cool
New York, Aug 31 (IANS) For double-income-no-kid (DINK) couples, raising a child is the most difficult part. For them, creches and day-care centres in the marketplace are no less than playing the role of real parents...
Read more on Celebrity Balla
 
Philippines seeking defence ties with India after China's moves
Manila, Aug 31 (IANS) Worried over increasingly aggressive moves of China to stake claim on disputed reefs in the South China Sea, the Philippines is looking at establishing defence cooperation with allies, including...
Read more on Politics Balla
 
Ancient metal workers were not treated as slaves
London, Aug 31 (IANS) Ancient metal workers were highly regarded for their skills and were not treated as slaves as popular narratives suggest, says a study. In the course of ongoing excavations at Timna Valley in...
Read more on Apple Balla
 
World Cup is all that matters, not rankings: Clarke
Melbourne, Aug 31 (IANS) Australia cricket captain Michael Clarke feels all that matters is winning the World Cup and not the rankings. Australia are currently the No.1 ranked ODI team followed by India and South...
Read more on Sport Balla
 
Kim's daughter to follow her beauty ritual soon?
Los Angeles, Aug 31 (IANS) It seems like reality TV star Kim Kardashian's 14-month-old daughter North will take after her mother when it comes to maintaining a strict beauty routine as the little one already likes...
Read more on Celebrity Balla